BOOK CHAPTER (215-232)
The legal status of illegitimate children from a historical perspective
More details
Hide details
1 |
Mediterranean University of Albania |
KEYWORDS
ABSTRACT
This article offers a longitudinal analysis of the legal status of children born outside lawful marriage, charting their treatment from antiquity through the present day. It begins by exam-ining ancient and Roman legal regimes, in which household affiliation and exceptional grants of legitimacy mitigated—but did not eliminate—the stigma of sui iuris descent. It then turns to the Middle Ages, where Christian morality and feudal custom imposed strict inheritance and civic restrictions on “illegitimate” offspring, albeit with localized legitimation practices such as the Mantelkinder ritual and papal rescripta. The study next surveys the early mod-ern and Napoleonic reforms that introduced codified paternity presumptions, voluntary ac-knowledgment, and legitimation by subsequent marriage or sovereign grace, culminating in Joseph II’s revolutionary decrees of formal parity. Finally, it assesses contemporary Euro-pean and supranational frameworks—particularly the EU Charter of Fundamental Rights, the ECHR, and Brussels II bis and Succession Regulations—which have abolished formal dis-tinctions based on birth status yet confront residual administrative and cultural barriers. By situating each epoch within its broader social and legal milieu, the article illuminates how historical doctrines continue to shape modern efforts to secure full equality for all children under the law.
REFERENCES (21)
1.
Albanian Civil Status Law No. 10129 (2009) as amended.
2.
Austrian Allgemeines Bürgerliches Gesetzbuch (1811). JGS Nr. 946/1811.
3.
Austrian Personenstandsgesetz Civil Status Act (2013). BGBl I Nr. 16/2013.
4.
Brussels II Regulation (EU) 2019/1111.
5.
Case C‑202/02 Commission v Italy.
6.
Case C‑300/90 Commission v Netherlands.
7.
Charter of Fundamental Rights of the European Union (2012). OJ C 326, 26.10.2012.
8.
Constitution of the Republic of Albania (1998).
9.
Elezi, I. (2010). E Drejta Familjare. Tirana: Pegi.
10.
European Convention on Human Rights (1950).
11.
Family Code of the Republic of Albania (2003). Law No. 9062.
12.
Floßman U. (2008). Österreichische Privatrechtsgeschichte Austrian private law histo-ry. Vienna: Verlag Österreich.
13.
Hübner R. (1930). Grundzüge des deutschen Privatrechts Fundamentals of German Pri-vate Law. Leipzig: Deichert.
14.
Kaser M./Knütel R. (2008). Römisches Privatrecht Roman Private Law. Münschen: C.H.BECK.
15.
Luidolt B. (2008). Römische Ehe und Lebensgemeinschaft verglichen mit modernen Konzepten Roman marriage and cohabitation compared with modern concepts. Ham-burg: Verlag Dr. Kovac.
16.
Marckx v Belgium App no 6833/74 (1979) (ECtHR, 13 June 1979).
17.
Planitz H. (1948). Deutsches Privatrecht German Private Law. Vienna: Springer.
18.
Regulation (EU) 650/2012.
19.
Schmidt, A. (2018). Familienrecht in Österreich. Vienna: Manz Verlag.
20.
United Nations Convention on the Rights of the Child (UNCRC), (1989).
21.
Weber, B. (2020). Paternity Establishment and Child Legitimization. Journal für Kinder- und Jugendhilfe 12(3), pp. 45–67.